It seems to me that this current pontificate has managed to polarise certain extreme views in the Church concerning the papacy itself. While these polarisations have been present for some time, only recently have they become mainstream.
On the one hand, we have the Neo-ultramontanists who assert that the Pope is chosen by God in the papal conclave. He cannot err on anything of importance and therefore any criticism of him is an attack on the papacy itself and the Catholic faith in general. On the other hand, we have the Sedevacantists who hold to the position that the Pope has erred and therefore he cannot be the Pope anymore. Thus they assert that the Chair of St. Peter (the papacy) is vacant.
May I submit to you that both of these groups are nothing more than two manifestations of the exact same error. That error being “Hyper-Papalism” (my own description).
What is Hyper-Papalism?
- The Anglicanorum Coetibus Society claims no rights to the photographs, videos and texts by third parties which are posted or quoted on this blog. If for any reason any object is called into question, or if the particular owner has an objection to its being displayed, please contact us and it will be removed.